New Guide! The Agentic AI Playbook  |

Download for Free
EP
24
July 15, 2024
Episode 24: Failing Forward: Big Flubs of the Past

Failing Forward: Big Flubs of the Past

Or listen on:

About the Episode

About the Episode:

Seth and Mallory candidly share some of their most memorable professional failures and the invaluable lessons they learned from them. From a pricey launch party oversight to a marketing and enrollment coordination mishap, they discuss how these blunders have shaped their approach to work and leadership. Tune in for an honest and humorous look at how embracing and learning from mistakes can lead to growth and success.

Key Takeaways:

  • Origami Challenge: Seth's personal journey to fold 1,000 paper cranes as a symbol of hope and self-reflection.
  • Failing Forward: Acknowledging that failures are essential for growth and improvement in any career.
  • Overspending Lesson: Mallory’s costly mistake at an AMA launch party highlights the importance of setting clear limits and planning for contingencies.
  • Under-Communication: Seth’s marketing campaign blunder at a previous job underscores the necessity of coordinating with all relevant teams.
  • Over-Communication: A misstep in over-communicating an idea at UCLA teaches the value of listening and understanding before presenting new concepts.
  • Website Redesign Woes: Mallory's recent challenge with Enrollify's website relaunch emphasizes the importance of thorough planning and proper execution.

Episode Summary

Owning Up to Flubs: Why Failure Matters

Mallory and Seth kick off the episode by admitting their hesitations about revisiting failures. However, they agree that openly discussing missteps can help others learn and grow. Whether it’s launching a website without proper coordination or underestimating the impact of event spending, each story offers valuable takeaways.

Story 1: Overspending on the Enrollify Launch Party

Mallory recounts hosting a wildly successful open bar event at AMA last year—so successful, in fact, that it ended with a five-figure bar tab. The mistake? Forgetting to set a spending limit or communicate budget constraints to the bar. While the event delivered huge buzz for Enrollify, the oversight highlighted the importance of proactive planning and ongoing ROI tracking for high-visibility initiatives.

Story 2: Under-Communicating in Marketing

Seth shares a costly mistake where he allocated significant marketing dollars during a high-demand season without confirming whether enrollment teams were staffed to handle the leads. The result? Overwhelmed teams and wasted marketing efforts. The lesson? Marketing success depends on cross-departmental collaboration and planning.

Story 3: Over-Communicating to the Wrong Audience

On the flip side, Seth also reflects on a meeting where he steamrolled a committee with an overly ambitious presentation, failing to listen or gauge what the group actually needed. The fallout—being removed from the committee—taught him to “seek first to understand, then to be understood.”

Story 4: Website Relaunch Without Stakeholder Buy-In

In what Seth describes as a "win that was actually a loss," he relays the story of launching a high-performing website redesign without involving key stakeholders in the process. While the redesign drove revenue, it damaged trust with other departments. Seth’s takeaway? True success requires bringing others along for the journey.

Story 5: Redirect Chaos in Enrollify’s Website Overhaul

Mallory shares a more recent failure: a glitch in the Enrollify website relaunch caused by incorrect redirects. Despite assurances that everything was ready, the oversight created additional work for her team and disrupted user experiences. This slip highlighted the importance of verifying critical elements yourself and asking the right questions early in the process.

A Final Word: Why Failing Forward Matters

This candid episode serves as a reminder that failure is a natural part of growth. The key is to reflect, learn, and apply those lessons moving forward. Mallory and Seth encourage listeners to share their own “flubs” and the insights they’ve gained. After all, the best leaders are those who turn mistakes into stepping stones.

Connect With Our Hosts:

Mallory Willsea
https://www.linkedin.com/in/mallorywillsea/
https://twitter.com/mallorywillsea

Seth Odell
https://www.linkedin.com/in/sethodell/
https://twitter.com/sethodell

About The Enrollify Podcast Network: The Higher Ed Pulse is a part of the Enrollify Podcast Network. If you like this podcast, chances are you’ll like other Enrollify shows too!  

Some of our favorites include Generation AI and Confessions of a Higher Education Social Media Manager.

Enrollify is made possible by Element451 —  the next-generation AI student engagement platform helping institutions create meaningful and personalized interactions with students. Learn more at element451.com.

People in this episode

Host

Mallory Willsea is the Chief Strategist and Producer of Enrollify — higher ed’s largest and most trusted podcast network - and host of The Higher Ed Pulse.

Seth Odell is Founder and CEO of Kanahoma, the fastest growing digital marketing agency in higher education, and host of The Higher Ed Pulse.

Interviewee

No items found.

Other episodes

Pulse Check: Practical AI Integration: How to Get Started — Pt. 1Play Button
Pulse Check: Practical AI Integration: How to Get Started — Pt. 1

Brian breaks down how custom GPTs—miniature AI tools trained on specific institutional data—are revolutionizing the way higher ed teams approach marketing, SEO, and student engagement.

Ep. 37: Shifting from Enrollment Pro to Enrollment Parent: the Surprises, Struggles, and StoriesPlay Button
Ep. 37: Shifting from Enrollment Pro to Enrollment Parent: the Surprises, Struggles, and Stories

Jenny Li Fowler sits down with Soup Campbell, Head of Community Experience at Zemi and a former dean of admissions, to explore what it’s like navigating the college admissions process from the other side — as a parent.

Episode #273: The Next Chapter in AI Literacy - What Educators Need to KnowPlay Button
Episode #273: The Next Chapter in AI Literacy - What Educators Need to Know

In this special episode recorded on site at SXSW EDU, Dustin chats with Annie Chechitelli, Chief Product Officer at Turnitin.

Episode 70: AI & Admissions: Making Fast, Fair Decisions in Higher EdPlay Button
Episode 70: AI & Admissions: Making Fast, Fair Decisions in Higher Ed

In this episode of Generation AI, hosts Dr. JC Bonilla and Ardis Kadiu examine how AI can support—not replace—human decision-makers in college admissions.

Episode 48: Using cold calls to turn direct mail into major giftsPlay Button
Episode 48: Using cold calls to turn direct mail into major gifts

Brenda, a certified fundraising executive with 16+ years of experience and nearly $1 billion raised, shares the exact tactic that made her outreach so effective.

Weekly ideas that make you smarter

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Subscribe